EXTRACTS FROM ‘ENABLE’
NEWSLETTER OF THE
ASSOCIATION
FOR
BETTER LAND HUSBANDRY
SET
1
Note
to readers of this on the TAA Website:
No.17
(July 2003) was added to the site first; No.16 (March 2003) was added later, but
appears on the list according to its date of publication, so now appears further
back in chronological sequence, before
No.17. Similarly, No.15 (July 2002)
and No.14 (Feb. 2002), though added later than Nos.17 and 16, now appear in
their proper order of publication date. Thus, if you have already read
only No. 17, you may not yet have read Nos. 16, 15 or 14, which are now
available on this website.
We
hope that the materials from ENABLE which appear from now on will be of
relevance irrespective of their date of first publication, so they will be
posted in order of receipt rather than date of
publication.
|
Contents Editorial:
Land
Husbandry and the
Natural
Science / Social Science Divide Article:
The Ecology and Prevention of Soil Erosion – R.G.Downes Bookshelf: Peter Storey’s ‘Good
News Level’ ‘Gaia
– The Practical Science of Planetary Medicine’ – J.Lovelock ‘The
Earth’s Dynamic Systems’ – W.K.Hamblin ‘Microcosmos’ – L.Margulis
& D./Sagan ‘Soil
Management and Conservation for Small Farms’ –
V.H.de Freitas Quotes. |
EDITORIAL
LAND HUSBANDRY
AND
THE SOCIAL SCIENCE / NATURAL SCIENCE
DIVIDE
For agriculture in the
tropics the pendulum of aid-agencies’ emphasis appears now to be swinging away
from the strong earlier stress on the scientific aspects of what is needed to
get agriculture moving and towards a strong relative stress on a social science
panacea. This swing is
perhaps understandable, because results of trying to apply purely technical
solutions to problems of inadequate plant production - which have a complex of
technical, social and economic causes - have not been as successful as
hoped.
In recent years it has
become abundantly clear that rural families’ motivations and constraints affect
their decisions about how best to manage land to improve their families’
conditions, and that purely-technical recommendations for improved plant
production may be unacceptable,
inappropriate or even downright damaging in this wider human context.
Growing sensitivity to, and
understanding of, farm-families’ conditions and aspirations makes easier the
growth of confidence – of farmers in their advisers, and of advisers in the
farmers they serve. Information and understanding of every sort can then move
more easily and credibly in both directions. While this can greatly improve the
rapport in rural areas, we should not see this as an end in itself, an
alternative to the technological approach, but rather as a valuable complement
to it, for the melding of both sets of ‘disciplines’ and the best use of their
different but interlinking sets of specific knowledge and
skills.
‘Land husbandry’ links the
two. Land, with its living and
non-living resources and water, is husbanded with lesser or greater skills by
people, so that soils may continue to produce plants and water on a sustainable
basis, on which all our livelihoods ultimately depend. What we as humankind have done to
land that has limited and diminished its potential for sustained satisfaction of
our various demands requires not just altered attitudes but also better
understanding of the land’s dynamic processes.
From this we must learn
better how to restore and then maintain its capacities for self-renewal through
the detailed technical understandings and possibilities which we have developed
over the last 100 years or more.
When populations were low relative to the abundance of fertile land, its
recovery after damage could be successfully maintained by shifting cultivation
and the adoption of ‘fallow’ periods which allowed sufficient time for
biological transformations to take place. No
longer. The temptation
is now to abandon ‘fallow’ as a concept, rather than to understand its necessity
as a means of sustaining productivity in the face of damaging tillage and trampling,
and in many situations the net loss of plant nutrients .
A
major challenge now is to understand better not only the minutiae of details and
processes as we take organisms and materials apart to look at their components,
but also how they fit together and function as living entities. When they lose their internal
organisation, they lose their usefulness and die. While we know much about what goes
on above the soil, we know comparatively little about what goes on – rather than
just what exists - below the soil surface, where plants’ roots live. Experiences with residue-based
zero-tillage systems in
This interdependence between
social and technical aspects of rural life is illustrated by the comments of a
well-respected Indian Professor of Agronomy with whom I used to work on an
Operational Research Project among 3 villages near
·
Win the confidence of the
farmers by whatever means, and be prepared to listen first and learn from
farmers;
·
Identify and analyse
constraints they face, including those off-farm as well as those
on-farm;
·
Be sure of success when demonstrating some quick result, in
any sphere;
·
Use a problem-solving
approach, offering an already-proven technology;
·
Enlighten farmers’
misconceptions by demonstrating realities of which they may not be
aware;
·
Keep close contact and
provide day-to-day guidance as they move to improve;
·
Ensure there is a good
feedback loop between farmers, extensionists and
researchers, working together in problem-solving and in the realisation of
possibilities;
·
Limited-period subsidies to
resource-poor farmers may be valuable in reducing the uncertainties involved
once they have decided to change towards improved
practices.
What
enabled the villagers to improve their agricultural livelihoods in ways that
persisted long after the formal end of the Project was the interlinkage of social and technical knowledge and skills
when helping the farmers to realise that they could indeed take some control of
their own destinies.
The
Editor.
ARTICLE
[This
significant article was published in 1959.
Its roots evidently go back to before 1949. Since this was written,
research and field observations may have altered understandings of the causes of
some of the problems, but the ecological realities remain. ABLH members will recognize
it as one of the sources for Dr Downes’ 1982 Brazil
consultancy report to FAO/TFS, on which is based the ABLH green-cover paper ‘An Ecological Background to Concepts of
Land Husbandry + Principles of Good Land Husbandry’ *. RGD’s vision and experience contributed much to the
philosophy behind our promotion of
* Obtainable from the Editor – T.F.Shaxson - for address see end.
THE
ECOLOGY AND PREVENTION OF SOIL EROSION
(formerly Chairman, Soil Conservation Authority of Victoria,
Australia)
Introduction
Accelerated soil erosion is a result of the
operation of the physical forces of wind and water on soil which has become
vulnerable because of man's interference with the natural environment. For this reason soil erosion can be
viewed as an ecological catastrophy
[sic], an upset in the balance of an environment which
can frequently lead to such significant changes that a new succession is
required to re-establish an ecological equilibrium.
Before the advent of civilized man, ecological
catastrophes probably occurred only at infrequent intervals, but for the past
3,000 years man has had a devastating influence in changing the face of the
earth. It is mainly because of his activities in certain kinds of environments
that soil erosion has occurred.
The most recent devastating changes in natural
environments have occurred in countries settled by white men, where a new human
culture has replaced an older one, and where forms of land use which may
have
been suitable for one kind of environment have been
applied in others in which there are significantly different
conditions.
New people in a new
environment
The natural environments of
There were three reasons for these
agricultural difficulties. The soils were poor; the strains of crop plants were
not suited to the different conditions of moisture, light and temperature; and
there was a shortage of skilled agriculturalists.
Since this inauspicious beginning,
exploration and settlement along with the breeding and adaptation of crops and
animals suitable for the new environments have advanced in
stages.
At first there was broad-scale use of
the land. The holdings were large
and open range grazing was practised. Small holdings close to towns provided
the major food requirements. About
a hundred years later, the large holdings in more favoured environments were subdivided into farms on
which a broad-scale agriculture developed. By
improvements in agricultural technology and machinery this type of farming
has reached a peak of efficiency with respect to production per
man.
During both of these stages of
development there was an attitude of exploitation which still persists in some
environments today. However,
in others the soil erosion resulting from the systems of land use and management
made men realize that their problems were not at an end, and that they had not
yet fitted onto their environment.
In the meantime, the closer settlement
in the better rainfall areas had virtually forced the broad-scale grazing into
the more arid environments and again there was trouble with soil erosion.
These events have drawn attention to the
need to move toward the final stage of the settlement and development of the
continent, that of soil conservation. It is now becoming more generally accepted
that by the use of all possible technological information, permanent systems of
land use can and must be devised and introduced for each of the many types of
environments. Only when this stage has been reached can civilized man be said to
have reached a balance with his environment.
However, the achievement of this
ambition is not without its problems which are plainly ecological in
character. Their solution will only
come from a more intimate knowledge of the different environments, and the
reasons why the land use systems which have already been imposed have upset the
balance, and what changes need to be made to re-establish an
equilibrium. It will need too, a more general appreciation that proper
land use is in fact applied ecology.
In spite of the problems which still remain to be
solved, the effect of settlement and development has been dramatic. From a small isolated penal settlement
unable to produce sufficient food for its needs there has developed a country
which now depends on its exports of primary produce for most of its overseas
income. This achievement has been gained at a price, the price of soil erosion
in many kinds of environment and even complete destruction in
some.
Such a result is not surprising when the habits of
the white settlers and their domesticated animals are compared ecologically with
those of the native people and fauna.
The effect of
settlement
Continental Australia has been isolated
from other land masses of the world since the early Tertiary period. In such isolation a characteristic flora
and fauna have evolved and survived without competition from species which have
subsequently been evolved in other parts of the world. In relation to area, the aboriginal and
fauna populations were small. These
species were able to survive because of their nomadic habit in seeking their
food requirements over vast areas in accordance with seasonal conditions. The
vegetation evolved under these conditions of light
pressure.
With the influx of white man and his
domesticated animals, the whole system was changed. Larger numbers of people and
of hard footed, closer-grazing animals were confined on specific areas in a
settled existence. The resulting
constant pressure on the environment irrespective of the variable climatic
conditions has had significant effects. Clearing of
vegetation, seasonal burning, cultivating and constant hard grazing were all
radical changes which have upset the ecological equilibrium in various kinds of
environments.
The various manifestations of wrong land
use and the upsetting of the ecological equilibrium are merely reflections of
how different environments have been able to react to the imposed conditions. In
some places, there has been little actual loss of soil but merely a declining
productivity due to deterioration of the physical condition, chemical fertility,
or moisture status of the soil. In
other places, there has been complete loss of vegetative cover and a hardening
of the soil to an arid and inhospitable environment for any form of
vegetation. In others, there have
been tremendous losses of soil from the surface and from scoured gullies. In
some wetter environments landslips have become frequent occurrences; while
in drier environments, sand dune systems have become unstable and are being
redistributed around the countryside.
These different effects of upsetting the
ecological equilibrium are indicators of the inherent weaknesses of the
different environments. In some places highly specialized vegetation could not
stand up to the imposed conditions;
in others, poorly structured soils collapsed completely under cultivation
and the pounding action of rain, and in others, naturally unstable topographic
conditions have become even more unstable.
Although soil erosion due to wind is an
important problem in large areas of the dry inland parts of
It would be wrong to imagine that soil
erosion in
The erosion which has taken place in
The problem of soil
conservation
Soil conservation in any environment is
fundamentally a problem of determining the correct form of land use and
management. The correct form of land use and management is one which provides a
higher level, or different form, of productivity than that available in the
natural state, but this new productivity must be capable of being maintained
indefinitely. This means that the balance of the natural environment must be
replaced by another balanced system under the changed form of land use. The
determination of correct land use is therefore a problem of applied
ecology.
Natural environments have evolved to a
condition where, from the available constellation of plant and animal species,
communities have developed in which there is a relative abundance of the various
species best able to survive in association and competition with each other
under the existing soil, climate, and topographic
conditions.
A natural environment represents a
maximum productivity of plants and animals at that stage of its succession, of
the species available during the developmental and evolutionary processes. It represents a permanent natural
productivity which will be maintained indefinitely or even increased by successional changes unless there is some catastrophic force
imposed on it. These naturally
infrequent catastrophies may result from geological
upheaval, vulcanism, climatic change, or the
occurrence of mutant species having overwhelming advantage in competition with
others.
However, except for seasonal changes
temporarily favouring one species against another,
natural environments are in a state of equilibrium over long periods. Even a run
of seasons favouring certain groups of species does
not significantly upset the balance to any marked extent, because these same
conditions inevitably favour predators or parasites
which will tend to reduce the numbers of the favoured
species. If not for these reasons, competition for food or water supply tends to
restore the environment to its normal condition once more.
Man's objective in land use is to either
raise the productivity of the environment or to produce in it other plants and
animals which are of more value to him. This requires a change in the
environment and the balance must be upset, but unless a new equilibrium is
established under the changed land use, the interference will set off a chain of
reactions comparable to those which could be expected only rarely under natural
conditions.
The ecological problem of land use and
soil conservation is the provision of more desirable species to occupy
artificially created niches from which a new equilibrium of maximum productivity
will result.
Since
There is a wide range [of] environments
and although there may be superficial similarity between some of them, each
presents its own particular problems of land use and development to achieve a
high level of permanent productivity and soil
conservation.
Some environments and their
problems
To outline the ecology of erosion and
conservation in many of the Australian environments would be a formidable
task. Only brief mention of a few
will be made here and one environment will be treated in more detail
later.
COSTIN (1954, 1957) has shown how man's
activity has led to instability and damage in the alpine and subalpine environments in S.E. Australia. Grazing and burning of
these natural alpine tussock grasslands (Poa caespitosa) has caused a deterioration and vegetative
change which has enabled both wind and water erosion to occur. In some
places the damage has been severe. In addition moss beds and bogs which normally
occur in the lower situations on the peneplain have
been dried out and destroyed as a result of stock trampling. The reclamation and
re-establishment of a balanced environment in these areas having an elevation of
more than 4,500 feet above sea level is difficult because of the harsh climatic
conditions, and the depletion of the plant species specialized for life in
such an environment.
In the wet sclerophyll forests successive forest fires have
obliterated certain valuable timber species in some areas, and in others
the more fire sensitive and more valuable species have been replaced by more
fire resistant forms. Clearing in the wet forest areas for use either for crops
or pasture has not been entirely successful. In the tropical areas high
intensity rains, even on the naturally well structured soils, have caused
considerable erosion. In the south,
although good pastures have been established in some places, the hydrological
balance has not been maintained. The replacement of deep rooting trees by
perennial grasses apparently enables the soils to become excessively wet at
depth and landslips become common.
In the drier areas BEADLE (1948) has
outlined the consequences of use of many kinds of environments in western
In even drier environments of the arid
interior, RATCLIFFE (1936) has described the ecological imbalance of certain
kinds of environments as a result of man's occupation and use. His discussion of ecological differences
between the natural and present use of the Saltbush (Atriplex vesicarium)
environment is particularly revealing. His conclusion concerning the proper
use of the dry country virtually means that it should be treated in the way it
was accustomed to being treated under natural conditions – “Inconstant stocking,
the figures varying between wide limits so as to take full advantage of the
flush [of] feed in good seasons and to avoid damage to the perennial vegetation
in bad." This is precisely the way
in which this country was used by the native fauna.
A difficult but interesting
environment
The ecological implications of erosion
control and soil conservation are exemplified by one particular type of
environment which occurs widely in Victoria, the south-eastern State of the
continent. In this environment there has been considerable instability and
consequent erosion of various kinds as a result of what had appeared to be a
reasonable and relatively mild form of land use.
The environment has a rolling to hilly
topography on which the original vegetation was a dry sclerophyll forest of Eucalyptus spp. with a sparse under-storey of shrubs and perennial
grasses. The rainfall ranges from
20" - 30" per annum most of which falls during the winter months which is the
growing season. Rainfall during the summer consists mainly of isolated
thunderstorms which are of little value for plant growth because of the hot
conditions and high evaporation. The hydrology of the environment is such that
rainfail and evapotranspiration approximately balance and consequently
there are no permanent streams. Flood flows can occur when rainfall intensity
exceeds the infiltration capacity of the soils or late in the winter when steady
rain falls on already saturated soils.
Under natural conditions there was a delicate hydrological balance. The soils are formed on fine sandstones
and shales and they are relatively shallow having an
average depth of from 3 to 4 feet.
The environment is subject to accession
of oceanic or ‘cyclic’ salts. ANDERSON (1941, 1945) and later LESLIE &
HUTTON (1958) have shown that over these areas about 10 to 30 lbs. of salt per
acre can be brought in by rain each year. These amounts of salt are in
themselves relatively insignificant except in those areas where the relation
between rainfall and evaporation precludes their complete leaching out of the
soil season by season, thus enabling their accumulation. DOWNES (1954) has
put forward the thesis that the soils in this environment are solodic, and have been formed as a result of the salinization and subsequent leaching of the pre-existing
soils. In recent geological time there have been significant changes of climate
which would have enabled considerable accumulation of salt during dry periods
and its subsequent leaching during wet periods within certain zones which can be
correlated with present day climatic limits. The zone in which this environment
occurs is one in which the most intensive solodization
would have been possible.
It is because of such a genesis that the
soils have certain properties which make them susceptible to the curious
forms of erosion which have subsequently occurred. The soils have a relatively shallow,
poorly structured, compact loam surface horizon over a bleached structureless subsurface horizon beneath which there is a
sharp transition to a heavy clay. The heavy clay
subsoil has a moderate medium subangular blocky
structure when dry, but when it is wet it disperses so readily that local
farmers talk of the subsoils as being
“sugary" because they "melt" so easily. In common with other
solodic soils they are acid throughout, have a low
content of soluble salts and low amounts of exchangeable calcium. In fact the
subsoils are hydrogen-magnesium
clays.
Although the problems of this type of country are
largely due to the character of the soils, the factors operating to produce such
soils are themselves of importance in enabling the operation of processes which
produce the problems. Man's
activity in this environment has merely been a reduction of tree cover in favour of grass and subsequent overgrazing of that grassland
but the results of such treatment have been spectacularly
bad.
The first significant disturbance of the
environment occurred about eighty years ago when the land was more closely
settled. Trees were thinned out and in some places completely cleared to
encourage a better growth of the existing perennial grasses of the Danthonia spp. and Stipa spp. This grassland
was grazed by sheep. However the grasses themselves had evolved under a
condition of occasional browsing by relatively few marsupials and were unable to
maintain density and vigour under the constant grazing
pressure of sheep, irrespective of the seasonal conditions. In addition, the
European rabbit had increased considerably in numbers and this added to the
grazing pressure on the vegetation.
Under such treatment the pastures deteriorated in
density and vigour and the exposed soil became hard
and compacted, the surface became impermeable, productivity declined, and soil
erosion became evident. The increased runoff scoured watercourses and they
became eroding gullies. But these were only preliminary
warnings.
About forty years ago it became evident that as
well as the more obvious effects of instability, more insidious troubles had
been developing. At that time the first signs of subsoil or tunnel erosion
appeared and it has subsequently developed into a widespread and difficult
problem.
Yet another problem emerged - the
development of salinity in the soils along some of the creek lines and
watercourses and on the lower parts of some slopes. At first it appeared to be a minor or
transitory problem, but like tunnel erosion, it too increased in incidence and
extent, more particularly during the past ten years.
Associated with both of these problems there was
the difficulty of establishing improved pastures. Many attempts by landholders
had met with outright failure, or at the best only poor germination and lack of
persistence. These failures were for many years attributed to climatic
conditions, although the climatic data offered no support for such
contentions.
Within a space of eighty years, a logical and
reasonable system of land use had resulted in a degree of degradation in many
places which could never have been imagined by the early settlers and appeared
to offer nothing to the present generation but further deterioration at an ever
increasing rate.
With the information now available about this
environment, it is easier to understand how these results were inevitable, and a
closer examination of the problems will reveal this.
Tunnel erosion is a most insidious form of erosion
because of the amount of deterioration which occurs before there is any visible
sign of damage. The earliest stages are marked by small patches of yellow clay
which have oozed through a small crack or ant hole to the surface. At a later
stage there may be conspicuous "fans" of yellow clay material which has been
washed down slope from small holes. At an even later stage there may be a line
of holes upslope from the point where the clay is being washed out. These holes occur where parts of the
surface soil have collapsed into the tunnel which has been eroded out of the
subsoil below.
The mechanism of tunnel erosion and the reasons for
its occurrence were put forward by DOWNES (1946). Basically it is due to
deterioration of pasture cover which enables the naturally poorly structured
surface soil to develop an impermeable surface condition. This enables increased
runoff from a large part of the area and less moisture for plant growth. But in
certain places there is an increase of infiltration by the concentration of
runoff water. Small natural hollows and old stump holes have better growth of
grass and an infiltration capacity of more than 50 times that of the surrounding
bare areas. In these places,
particularly after a dry summer, the water soaks in rapidly and as it passes
into the cracked subsoil it disperses some of the clay and carries it downslope until wetting and swelling of the clay prevents
any further such movement.
After many wet and dry seasons much clay
from beneath the hollow has been removed, the hollow enlarges and downslope from it there is a partly formed tunnel in the
subsoil but nothing visible above ground. At some critical time, possibly the
first autumn rain after a drought or prolonged dry summer, the quick movement
into the subsoil develops sufficient hydrostatic pressure downslope for some of the liquid clay to be forced through a
crack or ant hole to the surface. After the next dry season, when the clay has
dried and cracked, there is a complete channel into and out of the subsoil and
rapid scouring takes place from this stage to produce characteristic clay
"fans". Once tunnels have been formed, they provide a harbour for rabbits in country which previously had not been
a desirable habitat for them because the soils were too hard and compact for
easy burrowing. The invasion of rabbits adds to the grazing pressure and tends
to accentuate the trouble.
Tunnels deepen and widen until the roof of the
tunnel can no longer support its own weight and it collapses to form a
gully.
Salting in this kind of country was
first observed by HOLMES & LEEPER (1939) and later by DOWNES (1949) but it
was so limited in extent that it was thought to be of academic interest only.
However, recent investigations by COPE (1957) have indicated that it is
widespread and increasing; his work also confirms a hypothesis for salting which
was accepted but not investigated in detail by the previous
observers.
Salting results from an upset of the hydrologic
balance of the environment. The removal of trees to grow pastures is probably in
itself insufficient upset to cause salting, but when there is overgrazing in the
catchments and insufficient water use, the excess water seeps to lower levels
carrying with it the small amount of salt brought in by the rain. In this way
slightly saline water, if not used by vegetation in the areas of seepage,
enables a concentration of salt by evaporation and a level can be reached which
will inhibit plant growth. Stock tend to concentrate on
and eat out pastures growing on these seepage areas and this tends to intensify
incipient trouble. There is a characteristic succession of vegetation on the
seepage areas with the increasing accumulation of salt, the normal species
giving way to more halophytic species and ultimately even these will
die.
Early recognition of salting enables rapid
reclamation merely by improving water use in the catchment and fencing out the
incipient salt area to prevent overgrazing by stock. In advanced stages
however, reclamation is beset with all the problems normally associated
with soils of high salinity.
It is now becoming clearer that adequate water use
in catchments at least in some of the wetter areas,
cannot be properly achieved by improved annual pastures alone, and to restore a
hydrologic balance either perennial pastures or some trees will be needed if not
on the catchment, at least as buffer areas just above the seepage
areas.
For the correction of both tunnelling and salting the establishment of better
pasture cover is essential and until recently this has not been easy. ANDERSON
& MOYE (1952) showed that soils in New South Wales similar to these were
deficient in molybdenum and that they were too acid for the quick multiplication
of Rhizobium spp. to enable proper nodulation of subterranean clover.
Later this was confirmed for these soils by NEWMAN (1955) and pastures having
subterranean clover as the legume constituent can now be readily established
using lime-pelleted seed and molybdated superphosphate as
fertilizer.
It is not surprising that these soils should be
deficient in molybdenum in view of their mode of formation outlined by
DOWNES (1954). For the same reason it is not surprising that the
character of the soils should enable tunnelling, and
that salting should also occur.
In fact investigations show that the whole
environment is potentially unstable and requires careful handling to avoid
trouble. Possibly a little less intensive grazing could have avoided all of
these problems.
Nevertheless the better understanding of the total
environment has brought the solution of the problems and there has been a
general increase of productivity in recent years from a level of about ½ sheep
to the acre to more than 2 sheep to the acre in some
places.
Because such spectacular results have
been obtained, there is a tendency to forsake ecological principles in the
application of this new knowledge.
Thousands of acres of the steeper parts of this country are now being
seeded and topdressed from the air and many consider
that all the land use problems have been solved. However proper land use is a
dynamic thing in which the solution of one set of problems produces
others.
On such steep slopes it will be difficult to manage
the pastures to prevent clover dominance which after a time leads to a build-up
in the nitrogen status and an invasion of nitrogen-loving plants - mostly annual
grasses and weeds. The stability and higher productivity could be short
lived particularly if there were to be a run of drier than normal seasons. The replacement of native perennial
grasses by annual species - pastures at first and weeds
later - will not provide an adequate vegetative cover in times of drought. There
is a need to find out how to establish a useful perennial grass species along
with the clover so that use can be made of the improved nitrogen status to
prevent weed invasion and also to provide a reasonable cover in dry seasons.
Such problems must be recognized and solutions to them found if there is to be a
stable environment at a high level of productivity. Ecological ingenuity will be
required to solve them.
Soil and Ecological Surveys as a basis
for the determination
of land use
Because soil conservation is fundamentally an
ecological problem of adjusting the system of land use to suit the environment,
then it is essential to obtain all possible data concerning the various features
of each environment. Complete studies of areas reveal that environmental units
can be recognized. each of which by virtue of the integration of its particular
soils, climate, vegetation and topography provides the basis for determination
of suitable forms of land use which will provide for overcoming the problems and
hazards which it presents. Such units can be recognized at different levels of
generalization according to whether the determination of land use needs to be at
the broad scale,
that is, whether the unit is suitable for agriculture or
forestry; or at the narrow scale,
for individual farm planning where the problem is the assessment of suitability of areas for specific crops
or pastures.
DOWNES (1949) recognized the existence of such
units and their significance and called them units of land husbandry. These
units were at an intermediate scale between the two extremes mentioned above and
within each such unit a further subdivision of land classes was devised for the
purpose of farm planning.
CHRISTIAN et al. (1952) recognized land
systems as a broad unit in their study of large areas of land in northern
Australia.
DOWNES et al. (1957) have now
rationalized soil and ecological surveys on a reasonable basis which enables the
recognition and mapping of units at different levels of intensity and at the
same time provides a means of correlating the units and their relative
significance at these different levels. Four units are recognized, the
component, the land unit, the land system, and the geographic
zone.
The component is the unit recognized in
the most detailed investigation and is consequently the basic unit for
considering land use. A component
is uniform with respect to its potential, problems and hazards. Agronomic
investigations need to be based on components because they cannot be truly
related to a wider range of conditions. The component is an area of land in
which the climate, parent material, soil, vegetation and topography are uniform
within the limits significant for a particular form of land use. In practice when studying land for
potential development this is interpreted as being the most likely form of land
use. Thus in areas where irrigation is likely, the component would accommodate
soil variations of not greater than the tvpe-phase
level whereas for country where grazing of the native vegetation is likely to be
the land use, the range of variation within the component might be at a
sub-formation level for structure and sub-association level for floristics (sensu BEADLE
& COSTIN, 1952).
The land unit is an area in which there
are a limited number of components occurring in a consistent sequence to form a
characteristic pattern or landscape. It is the unit most commonly used for
mapping.
The land system is comparable with that
defined by CHRISTIAN et al. (1952) and consists of a combination of land units,
land form constituting the major factor of
grouping.
The geographic zone is a unit used for
the initial subdivision of large area of country and is an area in which similar
land systems are included, the chief land forms of the systems being
common.
To indicate the relative levels of generalization
the scales of the final map are: for components 40 chn
= 1 inch;
for land units 2 miles = 1 inch; for land systems 8 miles = 1 inch; and
geographic zones 32 miles = 1 inch.
Surveys in which land units are mapped provide a
compromise by which sufficient knowledge of the country is obtained for the
determination of land use with a reasonable speed of survey. Information is
obtained about all the components which occur within the land units and their
relative proportions and location in relation to each other. Such a survey
provides the preliminary information required for a detailed component survey if
this is required at a later date for the purposes of subdivision and farm
planning.
In conjunction with soil-ecological
surveys at all levels every effort is made to understand the origin and
development of the land forms, soils, and the vegetation types; in fact a
knowledge of the dynamics of the environment is an important aspect of the
investigations if the problems and hazards under likely forms of land use are to
be foreseen.
Agricultural ecology and farm planning
for conservation
Agriculture abounds in ecological problems, weed
control, and pasture establishment and management being excellent examples. But
in addition to such facets of agriculture in which the ecological implications
are obvious it is important to understand that the agricultural use of land is
an ecological problem.
Farm planning is the co-ordination of technological
knowledge into a system of land husbandry in which each part of the farm is put
to its best and proper use.
Ideally, good farming represents a situation in which man and his animals
have established a dynamically balanced ecological unit.
It is useless to consider individual technological
advances in isolation because any change imposed on the environment
results in other changes which can be either beneficial or
detrimental from either the physical or economic aspects. Farm planning consists in a basic
assessment of the natural resources of the farms and their potentiality. For
this purpose the farm needs to be classified on the basis of components or the
somewhat comparable units known to conservationists as land classes. The components can be readily characterised in terms of land
classes.
From this basic information the
alternative farming systems which can be safely and profitably used may be
determined and when the choice is made the detailed planning can
begin.
DICKINSON & DOWNES (1953)
have indicated the step-by-step procedure in farm planning for an area within the
type of problem country discussed earlier in this paper. The major subdivision is based on
a separation of land classes, since these areas will need different treatment
and management because of the different problems and hazards they present.
Subsequent subdivision aims to provide paddocks of the most efficient and
economical size to carry out the proposed system of farm management, to provide
water supply and access to paddocks which are aimed to give convenience, but at
the same time do not create hazards and subsequent erosion
To indicate the complexity of such a
total approach the factors influencing the final paddock size on a sheep grazing
property can be elaborated.
Initially the soil, slope, climate, and aspect, will determine the type
of pasture and potential productivity. The type of pasture will determine the type
of grazing management with respect
to the grazing pressure to be applied in accordance with the season of
the year, and the frequency with which it shall be left for a hay crop. To obtain the proper grazing pressure on
the right occasions requires careful flock management procedure, and,
according to flock management methods and breeding programme, so does the paddock size need to be designed. In
addition to these criteria the water supply facilities need to be designed to
enable the combined pasture and flock management programme to be carried out as
planned.
So farm planning for
conservation and proper use of an environment is a process of integration of
knowledge of the behaviour of plants and animals in
relation to each other and their environment, truly a problem of applied
ecology.
The whole basis of soil conservation,
erosion control and reclamation is ecological. For soil conservation there is a
need to assess the nature and dynamics of environments so that systems of land
use can be devised to give the desired production on a permanent
basis.
Erosion control is basically an
understanding of the reasons for the upset equilibrium and the mechanics of
erosion processes to devise methods for re-establishing a balance. Reclamation is a matter of assessing the
nature of the modified environment so that suitable primary and secondary
[plant] colonizers can be found to occupy the available niches and so begin a
succession to a new equilibrium.
REFERENCES
ANDERSON. A. J. & MOYE. D. V.
1952. Lime &
Molybdenum in Clover Development on Acid Soils. Aust. J. agric. Res.
3, 95.
ANDERSON, V. G., 1941. The Origin of
Dissolved Inorganic Solids in Natural Waters in
ANDERSON. V. G.. 1945. Some Effects of Atmospheric Evaporation and
Transpiration on the Composition of Natural Waters in Aust.
J. Aust. Chem. Inst. 12,
41.
BEADLE. N. C. W., 1948. The Vegetation &
Pastures of Western N.S.W. with special reference to Soil Erosion. N.S.W.
Govt. Printer. 281. pps.
BEADLE, N. C.
W. & COSTIN. A. B.. 1952. Ecological
Classification & Nomenclature. Proc. Linn. Soc. N.S.W. 61,
77.
CHRISTIAN. C. S. & STEWART.
G. A.. 1953. Survey of the Katherine-Darwin
Region. Land Research Series No. 1, C.S.I.R.O. Australia.
COPE. F.,
1955. Catchment Salting in
COSTIN, A. B.. 1954. The Ecosystems of the Monaro Region of N.S.W. N.S.W. Govt.
Printer. 360 pps.
COSTIN, A. B.,
1957.
DICKINSON, H. R. &
DOWNES. R. G.. 1953. The Westgate Farm Planning Project. Soil Conservation Authority of Vic.
DOWNES. R. G., 1946. Tunnelling Erosion in North
DOWNES, R. G. 1949.
DOWNES, R. G..
1954. Cyclic Salt as a Factor in the Genesis of Soils in S.E. Aust. Aust.. J. agric. Res.
5.448.
DOWNES, R. G. 1956. Conservation Problems on Solodic Soils in
DOWNES. R. G.. GIBBONS. F. R., ROWAN. J. M. & SIBLEY,
G. T., 1957. Principles & Methods of Ecological
Surveys for Land Use Purposes. Second Aust. Conf. in Soil Science. MeIb.,
1957.
HOLMES, L. C.. LEEPER, C. W. & NICOLLS, K. D.. 1939. Soil & Land Use Survey of the country around
Berwick. Proc. Roy. Soc. Vic. N.S. 52.
177.
LESLIE. T. I. & HUTTON, J. T.
1958. Accession of Non Nitrogenous Ions in Rainwater in
NEWMAN, R. J., 1955. Molybdenum deficiency in Central Highlands & Upper Goulburn Regions. Vict. Vic. J.
Dept. Agri. 53.
451
RATCLIFFE. F. N., 1936. Soil Drift in the
Arid Pastoral Areas of Sth. Aust.
C.S.I.R.O. Aust., . Pamph. No.64.
RATCLIFFE, F. N., 1937. Further Observations on Soil Erosion & Sand Drift with Special
Reference to S.W.
[From: Biogeography and Ecology in
Australia. Monografiae
Biologicae. Vol. VIII
pp.472-486.
Comment –
2001
The
opportunities for land-use assessment, followed by ecologically-oriented farm
planning based upon it as described above, are becoming ever-less frequent in the places
where farms of multitudes of
resource-poor people cover the landscape. The dynamic ecological realities
still operate, nevertheless.
In the past we used to propose a range of different types of land
use – e.g. ‘arable’, ‘pasture’, ‘forestry’ - to fit different land units
identified in the landscape, and assumed the standard form of management
for each use would be employed.
Nowadays it is the possible variations in type of management of
the preferred land use (often dominated by an annual staple crop such as maize)
which can provide the necessary flexibility in fitting a very limited number of
uses into the ecological niches of the land. Residue-based zero-tillage systems
can come close to the ideal blending of both aspects.
T.F.S.
.oOo.
“We have met the enemy, and he is us”.
Pogo, reporting to his
king.
.oOo.
BOOKSHELF
PETER STOREY’S ‘GOOD NEWS LEVEL’
Note by
David Sanders
“I met
Peter Storey earlier [in 2000] at the annual workshop of the Association for
Better Land Husbandry in England where he demonstrated his ‘Good News
Level’. Peter is a member of
WASWC and an interesting person.
He worked for many years in Asia on rural development and soil
conservation projects.
While
working in Nepal, he needed a simple and cheap level that could be used by
illiterate farmers to lay out terraces and other works. Like many of us who have worked in
similar situations, Peter experimented with simple levels, including a water
tube level, spirit level hanging from a string, and an ‘A frame’. None of
these
proved satisfactory so he set about inventing his own level and came up with the
Good News Level, a simple instrument made out of four pieces of wood, three
bolts, nuts, and washers and a simple plumb-bob.
The
level is like an inverted L with a diagonal cross-brace, and a bob weight and
plumbline hanging down the upright. The horizontal bar is used as a
sighting bar by the ‘surveyor’ to look along to a ‘staff-man’
holding a sight stick at any required distance up to 100 metres. The staff man places his hand and
arm in a line with a mark on the sight stick which is at the same height as the
sighting bar. He then moves
up and down the slope as directed by the surveyor until his hand and arm are
exactly in line with the sight bar.
He can then place a marker indicating that the position [of the
sight-stick] is exactly level with the position of the level
[instrument].
The
level can also be used for six other calculations, including marking out graded
(sloping) contour lines; measuring
the percentage grade or slope of a hill;
measuring the vertical distance between contour lines; and setting out the angles of terrace
walls, and the angle of terrace backslopes. It can also be used when planning
water systems, e.g.: if a pipeline or an irrigation canal is to have a 2% slope
from the source to the area of need, where will the water be delivered? If a pipe is to be laid from a
source to a place below the source, what is the head drop to that place? From this it can be determined
what grade of pipe is required or if a break pressure tank is
required.
Peter
says: “It is GOOD NEWS, as local people in the hilly areas can make it, and with
an hour’s practice, illiterate people can use it. They can set out quickly, and
accurately, level contour lines or graded contour lines and can determine where
to set the succeeding contour lines.
They can also learn other surveys and calculations needed for soil and
water conservation projects”.
Peter is presently working on two detailed manuals on soil and water
conservation and soil improvement [with the overall title ‘The Conservation and
Improvement of Sloping Lands’]. He describes Volume I [‘Practical
Understanding’] as a “practical theory on the subject”. It is intended for policy makers,
donor organisations, large rural development projects, colleges, and
universities. Volume IIa and b [‘Practical Applications’] is aimed at practical
rural development projects, extension workers and farmers.
Full
details of how to make and use the Good News Level are given in a book that he
has already written, ‘BAMBOO, a Valuable
Multi-purpose and Soil Conserving Crop’. The
Bamboo book has much relevance to soil conservation, in particular for
converting actual or potential landslide areas into stable, useful and profitable.areas.
Anyone
interested in obtaining more information or buying the Bamboo book should write
to Peter Storey at: 38 Bellingham Road, Cumbria LA9 5JW, England, or contact him
at pj@rosebeck.freeserve.co.uk on
e-mail. I understand that the
book is being sold at about UK £7 (about $11 U.S.).”
This
review first appeared in the WASWC Newsletter Vol.16 No.3, August
2000. Peter Storey recently
provided the up-dated information.
.oOo.
The books mentioned below provide different aspects of a coherent context within which to set the concepts, necessity and practicalities of better land husbandry. T.F.Shaxson.
‘GAIA – THE PRACTICAL SCIENCE OF PLANETARY MEDICINE’
James
Lovelock
“Viewed
from the distance of the moon, the astonishing thing about the earth, catching
the breath, is that it is alive.
The photographs show the dry, pounded surface of the moon in the
foreground, dead as an old bone.
Aloft, floating free beneath the moist gleaming membrane of bright blue
sky, is the rising earth, the only exuberant thing in
this part of the cosmos. If
you could look long enough, you would see the swirling of the great drifts of
white clouds, covering and uncovering the half-hidden masses of land. If you had been looking a very
long, geological time, you could have seen the continents themselves in motion,
drifting apart on their crustal plates, held aloft by
the fire beneath. It has the
organized, self-contained look of a live creature, full of information,
marvellously skilled in handling the sun”.
(Lewis Thomas. From: ‘The Lives of a Cell’.,
quoted in: Lovelock J., 1988 ‘The Ages of Gaia – A Biography of our Living
Earth’. Oxford: OUP).
In this
book Prof. Lovelock further elaborates the basis of a unified view of the earth
and life sciences, the Gaia Hypothesis, which suggests that the planetary
ecosystem can be described as alive, because it behaves like a living organism to
the extent that temperature and chemical composition are actively kept constant
in the face of perturbations.
His use of the term ‘alive’ is like that of an engineer who calls a
mechanical system alive to distinguish its behaviour when switched on from that
when switched off. Chapter headings
are: Recognising Gaia;
Anatomy;
Physiology; Epigenesis; Biochemistry and the Cell; Metabolism and Planetary Chemistry; Physiology and Climate Regulation; The People Plague.
“Gaia
theory may be wholly or partially in error. To a real scientist this is not as
important as how well the theory fits these criteria :
Is it useful? Does it suggest
interesting experiments? Does it
explain the puzzling data we have gathered? What are its predictions? Does it have a mathematical basis? Gaia gives positive answers to all of
these questions and therefore surely merits consideration, not contumely, from
scientists”. (in Author’s Preface, p.7).
Lovelock J,
1991. Gaia – The Practical
Science of Planetary Medicine. London: Gaia Books Ltd.
192pp. ISBN 1-85675-040-X. (hbk.).
.oOo.
[Though
the next book was reviewed in ENABLE 7, it is appropriate to mention it again,
because it fits into this sequence of these four books which complement each
other.
Editor]
]
‘THE EARTH’S DYNAMIC SYSTEMS’
W.Kenneth
Hamblin
“Beginning
geology students commonly suffocate in an avalanche of information without a
unifying theme to help them grasp fundamental ideas and important
relationships. The core theme
in this book is the Earth’s dynamic systems, just as the title states. There are two major energy systems
that make the Earth a dynamic planet:
one is a hydrologic system, the circulation of water over the Earth’s
surface, which involves the movement of water in the ocean, rivers, underground
and in glaciers. The other is
the tectonic system: the
movement of material powered by heat from the Earth’s
interior. This system
involves the evolution of continents and ocean basins, and
mountain-building. These two
systems are the focus of this book, and everything discussed in it can be
related to these two unifying themes”.
(in Author’s
Preface).
You do
not have to be a geology student already to benefit from this absorbing book –
indeed, it is more likely to make you want to study
geology in more detail as a result of reading it. Its contents are grouped under the
chapter headings: The Planet Earth;
The Hydrologic System; The
Tectonic System; Minerals; Igneous Rocks; Sedimentary Rocks; Metamorphic Rocks; Geologic Time; Weathering; River Systems; Processes of Stream Erosion and
Deposition; Evolution of
Landforms; Groundwater
Systems; Glacial Systems; Shoreline Systems; Eolian
Systems; Plate Tectonics; The Earth’s Seismicity;
Volcanism; Crustal Deformation;
Evolution of the Ocean Basins;
Evolution of the Continents;
Environment, Resources and Energy;
Planetary Geology. Each
chapter is set out under the sub-headings: Outline of Major Concepts; Guiding
Questions; Summary; Key Terms; Review Questions; Additional Reading; Glossary. This makes the book extremely
well-organised and easy to understand. This is further enhanced by the
excellent photographs and diagrams which liberally illustrate the writing. As a teaching text, it is
complemented by a Student Study Guide, Laboratory Manual, a set of 200 slides,
and an Instructor’s Guide.
Hamblin W.K., 1989. The
Earth’s Dynamic Systems : A Textbook in Physical
Geology (5th edition). London:
Collier MacMillan Publishers. 576pp.
ISBN 0-02-349381-X. (hbk.).
.oOo.
‘MICROCOSMOS – FOUR BILLION YEARS OF
MICROBIAL EVOLUTION’
Lynn Margulis and Dorion Sagan
Hamblin’s
book ‘The Earth’s Dynamic Systems’ [above] highlights two main
energy systems - the tectonic and hydrological systems. ‘Microcosmos’ describes a third, that of biological
systems, and in particular the role of micro-organisms in living systems, from
the origin of life through to their continuing vital importance in current ecosystems, of
which mankind is a recent and dangerous component.
“In
‘Microcosmos’ we retrace evolutionary history
from the perspective of the bacteria. Bacteria, single and
multi-cellular, small in size and huge in environmental influence, were the sole
inhabitants of Earth from the inception of life nearly four billion years ago
until the evolution of cells with nuclei some two billion years later. The first bacteria were
anaerobes: they were poisoned by
the very oxygen some of them produced as waste. They breathed in an atmosphere
that contained energetic compounds like hydrogen sulfide and methane. From the microcosmic perspective,
plant life and animal life, including the evolution of humanity, are recent,
passing phenomena within a far older and more fundamental microbial world. …
We show
how it is … foolish to overlook the crucial importance of physical association
between organisms of different species, symbioses, as a major source of
evolutionary novelty. And
during the last half decade events and moods have tended to underscore the
importance of symbiosis and association far beyond the micro-world of evolving
bacteria”. (pp.7,17).
The
insights provided by this book are very relevant to the subject of land
husbandry. There is a
necessary and growing emphasis on what goes on beneath the soil surface in the
root-zone, where micro-organic activity plays key biological roles in
sustainability of agricultural activities through its capacities to create and
re-create soil architecture, mediate the capture and release of plant nutrients,
favour plants’ rooting, and improve streamflow
conditions.
“Microcosmos
is one of those rare books which permanently changes
the mind of the reader. The
natural world will never look the same again, even if a lot of it is
invisible. The book is
written with style and clarity, unencumbered by jargon.”
(Crispin
Tickell, on back
cover)
Margulis L. and
Sagan D., 1997. Microcosmos – Four Billion Years of
Microbial Evolution.
London: Univ. of California Press. 300pp.
ISBN 0-520-21064-6 (pbk.).
.oOo.
‘SOIL MANAGEMENT AND CONSERVATION FOR SMALL FARMS’
Valdemar Hercilio de Freitas
“The
report is intended for development practitioners, extensionists and leaders or pioneers in farming
communities, to inform them about the experiences and initiatives of farming
communities in conservation agriculture in Santa Catarina State, Brazil. On the basis of several local
initiatives, inventions and developments there have been widespread improvements
in soil management in various parts of the State, resulting in lower costs and
improved returns, combined with conservation and improvement of the soil
resources. The main elements
of success were minimum tillage, soil cover and direct seeding practices and
equipment, together with an effective and creative extension service. While these developments probably
cannot be duplicated as such elsewhere, the methods and strategies may well
inspire others to adapt and modify them for application in their own
environments”. (Description on back cover).
The
publication is subtitled ‘Strategies and methods of introduction, technologies
and equipment’. This
well-illustrated and informative FAO Soils Bulletin describes in
detail what occurs when farmers apply improved husbandry of land, and provides
institutional as well as technical guidelines to what is needed to make this
possible. The effects
of better land husbandry are demonstrated as realities which are favoured by
farmers. Most of the five-fold spread - from 124,000 hectares to 685,000
hectares - which took place between 1994 and 1997 was through farmer-to-farmer
interaction.
The
process of agricultural improvement was facilitated by a World Bank loan for
strengthening local capacities.
The following assessment of Project outcome is extracted from the Bank’s
Implementation Completion Report dated
“The
overall assessment of the project is highly satisfactory. Although ex-post
evaluations were complicated by drought, productivity of the main crops – maize,
wheat and soyabeans – is estimated to exceed without
project productivity by 20 to 35%.
Soil loss was reduced by between 10 and 50%. Runoff water in streams contained
less suspended solids, coliform bacteria and pesticide
residues, thus lowering silting and water treatment costs in downstream areas,
and reducing the incidence of waterborne diseases and pesticide poisoning. Maintenance
costs for rural roads were reduced by up to 80%; better all-weather access
stimulated both commercial and social activities. Improved land management
practices, capable collectively of increasing water retention on crop land,
improving soil structure, raising fertility and reducing erosion , were adopted on some 400,000 ha. in 534 assisted microcatchments
(103% of the appraisal target).
About 106,000 farm families were reached with one form or another of
project assistance – 131% of the appraisal target and equal to about 35% of all
farmers in the State.
Spontaneous adoption of improved practices occurred on a further 480,000
ha. in non-project catchments …”.
This
FAO document is both a record of how this happened and a guidepost to comparable
development in the future.
De Freitas V.H., 2000.
Soil Conservation and Management for Small Farms
: Experiences from the State of
.oOo.
Quotes
“… If we make many mistakes
in management but we deliberately or accidentally get the management of the soil
surface correct, the whole thing tends to come right; it’s very forgiving. If we manage everything else to
perfection, but either accidentally or deliberately expose the soil to raindrop
action, no matter what else we do, it will tend to go wrong. That’s the key to why so much
well-meant effort … has gone wrong.
It isn’t from lack of motivation or anything else. It is through this accidental
misunderstanding of the importance of the soil surface”.
Alan
Savory. ‘Rangeland
Revolutionary’. JSWC July-Aug.1984.
.oOo.
“The use of travelling is
regulate imagination by reality, and instead of
thinking how things may be, to see them as they are”.
Dr. Samuel Johnson.
.oOo.
PUBLICATION DETAILS: ”ENABLE” IS [WAS] THE NEWSLETTER OF THE ASSOCIATION
FOR BETTER LAND HUSBANDRY (U.K.REGD. CHARITY
1025653). AUTHORS ARE
RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIEWS EXPRESSED IN THEIR PAPERS WHICH ARE NOT NECESSARILY
THOSE OF THE ASSOCIATION. THE
NEWSLETTER FUNCTIONS AS A FORUM FOR NEWS AND DISCUSSION OF ISSUES RELATED TO
PROMOTING BETTER LAND HUSBANDRY, AND WELCOMES CONTRIBUTIONS ESPECIALLY FROM ABLH
MEMBERS AND ALSO FROM OTHER INTERESTED PERSONS. CONTRIBUTIONS SHOULD BE SUBMITTED
– PREFERABLY BY E-MAIL, OR ON DISKETTE IN MS-WORD FORMAT – TO THE EDITOR: FRANCIS SHAXSON, GREENSBRIDGE,
.oOo.
[The material above is taken from ENABLE Number 13, July
2001]